Home » Business » Taxes and America’s Social Contract

Taxes and America’s Social Contract

Follow me on Twitter

The American social contract is threadbare in certain parts of America.  Areas of this great country are falling into disrepair, dissolution as if under a spell . In places like the Camden, New Jersey and now Josephine County, Oregon, public safety has been compromised by the failure of will to raise taxes.   Below you will find a very disturbing report on the latter situation from Oregon Public Broadcasting.  It dramatically highlights what can go wrong when citizens can’t make the connection between good government and the tax revenue it takes to have it.  First, let’s consider the various segments of our population who oppose raising taxes.

There are those who see themselves through the lens of American individualism.  They value self-reliance and see this as a patriotic duty.  They tend to think less of those who are more collaborative or more dependent or unsuccessful. They tend to discount the contribution of the public commons to their own welfare and don’t often recognize how massively interdependent our advanced society really is.  They believe that less government is best for everyone.  These folks are less willing to contribute to tax supported government services other than for military defense.  They are  ideological individualist. They may include libertarians. On the extreme fringe they may include anarchists or survialists.

There are those who are suspicious or uncomfortable with Ameican pluarism.  These folks most often live in parts of the country where there is little diversity or only a single other minority group.  But folks who hold this belief  can also be  found everywhere.  They believe a disproportionate amount of their taxes go to support other ethnic or cultual groups whose members don’t share their same values or work ethic. They sometimes fear other groups are taking advantage of government largess.  As a result, they are more resentful of paying taxes and more critical of wasteful governement spending.  They are  pluralism-adverse. At the extremes this group may include racists and hate group. A highly nationalistic subset of this pluralism adverse group believes the federal government has already broken faith with the people and threat our liberty.  For them, paying taxes is akin to paying tribute to a foreign potentate.

There are some religious fundamentalists who believe all secular government is evil. For them, anything that expands government is evil as well, including raising taxes.

There are those who believe taxes compete or interfere with commerce and the free market.   They think that taxes only reduce the capital available for business and contribute to government regulations. They don’t see government spending as stimulating for the economy.  For them, the provision of services to those who aren’t successful contributors to the economy is an unfair redistribution of wealth.  This group are more likely to have higher incomes and to pride themselves in their ability to avoid paying taxes. In the extreme they tend to see society as made of the have and have nots, the makers and the takers.

I believe all these groups are being aggitated and moulded into an anti-government political movement to reduce the power of government to regulate powerful corporate interests.  But regardless of what you or I believe, the truth of who we are becoming is reflected in the hopes and fears of this 911 caller in Josephine County, Oregon.

With No Officers To Respond To 911 Calls, Josephine Co. Considers Tax Levy

OPB | May 14, 2013 3:40 p.m. | Updated: May 15, 2013 10:50 a.m. | Grants Pass, Oregon



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: